The BMW had a six-speed manual transmission and approximately 85,000 kilometres. It was the kind of car we enjoy: compact, powerful and engaging to drive.
It also had an encouraging history. The BMW dealership selling it had originally sold the car to its first owner, maintained it and later purchased it back. On paper, it looked like an excellent candidate for our showroom.
At Lee Munro’s Garage, we talk about selecting the right vehicles. Sometimes that means making a difficult decision about a car we’ve already purchased. A 2013 BMW 135i transmission problem recently put that commitment to the test.
Then we drove it.
The BMW 135i transmission problem
During our evaluation, we discovered that the transmission ground when shifting into second gear. We contacted the selling dealership, which contributed $4,000 toward the problem, and began looking for a dependable repair.
We spoke with transmission specialists, parts suppliers and BMW dealerships. Through the sources we contacted, we couldn’t find the internal parts needed to repair the transmission or a replacement available from stock. One dealership offered to order a new transmission from Germany for approximately $11,000, payable in advance, without a guaranteed delivery date.
We even purchased a used transmission in the hope of finding a solution. Unfortunately, it had the same problem.
The car was worth approximately $20,000 in good condition. The potential cost of a replacement and installation approached $12,000, and we still couldn’t be confident when a new transmission would arrive.
The decision
We could have disclosed the problem, reduced the price and offered the BMW for sale. But disclosure alone would not have given a retail customer a dependable solution.
We decided the car did not meet the standard we set for vehicles in our showroom.
After further discussion, the selling BMW dealership agreed to buy the car back. We were left with $2,697.29 in unrecovered reconditioning costs, in addition to the time spent investigating the problem.
That was a disappointing result. But it was the right decision for our customers and for the way we want to do business.
Selection means more than buying
Every used vehicle has a history. Many have items that can be repaired or serviced as part of preparing them properly. Occasionally, a car presents a problem for which we cannot find a solution we’re comfortable passing on to a customer.
That’s why we take the time to inspect, drive and get to know the vehicles we buy. The work includes independent and in-house inspections, reconditioning, detailing and Ontario safety certification before a vehicle is advertised. Our preparation is included in the price. You can read more about how we select and prepare our vehicles.
The BMW was an appealing car with a reassuring history and relatively low mileage. It also had a problem we could not resolve to our satisfaction. In this case, the best decision was not to offer it for retail sale.
What we keep out of our showroom is every bit as important as what we put into it.
Lee Munro
Lee Munro’s Garage
Selected. Prepared. Ready to Enjoy.